Paleo Thanksgiving Menus

Paleo Thanksgiving Menu

Whether you’re cooking up a fantabulous feast for Thanksgiving, looking for a new side dish or just browsing for recipe inspiration, this Paleo Thanksgiving Recipe Roundup is your one-stop shop.

This guide will make it super easy to peruse our favorite Paleo recipes and I’ve also included my Paleo Thanksgiving menu so you can see an example of what works well together. :)

If you’re not into turkey, no problem. I’ve included a few different main course options as alternatives. Although, if turkey is your crown jewel, my bacon-wrapped turkey will definitely shine with Paleo and non-Paleo eaters alike.

Paleo Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is rarely about the turkey, it’s more about all the glorious sides (well actually it’s probably about joining together with close family and friends, but I’m talking food here, people!). :) Whether you’re looking for something simple or more elaborate the sides tend to come down to a vegetable matched with a preparation method.

My 2014 Paleo Thanksgiving Menu

In the past, I have only needed to prepare a side or two because in our family, since before I was born my mom has prepared the Thanksgiving feast.

When Jeff & I started dating, we started splitting the day in half. First we would enjoy an extravagant lunch that Jeff’s mom would slave over and prepare super early so that we could then head directly over to my parents house for (second) dinner, i.e. another fully prepared turkey dinner with all the fixins!

In 2014 I decided it would be much easier if I prepared the Thanksgiving dinner and invited everyone over to our place. It saved both of our moms from having to prepare meals separately and we didn’t have to split our time…and save enough room to enjoy both meals!

This is my Paleo Thanksgiving menu, which I prepared for 15 people in 2014:

Maple Brussels Sprouts

Prepare A Simple Dish

Don’t let fancy side dishes scare you away, you can prepare something simple and it can absolutely taste delicious. For example you can choose carrots, celery, broccoli, brussels sprouts, parsnips, pumpkin, squash, asparagus, etc. and each one can be prepared in an assortment of ways: baked, mashed, boiled, pan-fried or any other way you see fit. It’s really as simple as combining a vegetable or two, choosing your cooking method and then adding in an herb, seasoning, and/or fat.

But Thanksgiving day is not the time to be experimenting, so leave that to me and feel free to peruse what I’ve already tested and shared below.

Enjoy your time with family and friends and if you give any of my recipes a try, let me know how they turn out for ya! :)

More Thanksgiving Menu Ideas

Unless you’re really hungry, this isn’t meant to be a single menu. But if you want a fan-freaking-tastic Thanksgiving or you’re feeling like superwoman (or -man), then have at it! ;)


Simple Deviled Eggs
Bacon Wrapped Paleo Jalapeno Popppers
Egg Salad in a Peppadew for Paleo Thanksgiving Roundup Menu


Paleo Garlic Mashed Cauliflower
Mashed Rutabaga for Paleo Thanksgiving Menu
Lemon Brussels Sprouts Chard
Paleo Mashed Parsnips with Bacon
Paleo Baked Cauliflower Casserole
Scalloped Kohlrabi for Paleo Thanksgiving Roundup Menu
Maple Paleo Cornbread
Paleo Stuffing
Pomegranate Paleo Relish
Paleo Biscuits for Paleo Thanksgiving Roundup Menu

Main Course

Paleo Bacon Wrapped Turkey
Paleo Braised Lamb
Braised Paleo Bottom Round Roast
Braised Pork and Pears
Paleo Ham Recipe


Paleo Pumpkin Pie
Cranberry Chocolate Chip Paleo Ice Cream

Happy Thanksgiving!

Jeff and Marla Sarris
Love, Jeff & Marla :)